How Security Teams Use Vendor Risk Data to Gain Leverage During Procurement and Renewal

The Moment You Have the Most Vendor Security Leverage

Most organizations think vendor risk management happens after a contract is signed.

In reality, the best chance to reduce risk happens before the contract is finalized or when it comes up for renewal.

Once the deal is signed and systems are integrated, switching vendors becomes expensive and disruptive. At that point, leverage drops quickly.

But during procurement or renewal?

That’s when security and risk teams have real influence.

They can push for:

• Better security commitments
• Incident notification requirements
• Cyber insurance coverage
• Data protection guarantees
• Security roadmap commitments
• Compliance requirements

And increasingly, organizations are using vendor risk intelligence to strengthen their negotiating position.

Why Vendor Risk Matters More Than Ever

Vendor ecosystems have expanded rapidly over the last decade, increasing exposure for organizations everywhere.

Recent research highlights the scale of the problem:

• According to a 2024 PwC Global Digital Trust Insights report, 57% of organizations experienced a data breach costing over $1 million in the past three years, and many incidents originated through third parties.
• A World Economic Forum cyber report found that supply-chain and ecosystem risks are now among the top global cybersecurity concerns for executives worldwide.
• A Deloitte global survey found organizations now rely on hundreds of third parties, yet many lack visibility into vendor security maturity.

Vendor risk is no longer just a security problem; it’s a business resilience issue.

And procurement decisions play a critical role.

Why Leverage Disappears After Signing

After a contract is signed:

• Switching vendors becomes expensive
• Integrations are already built
• Teams rely on vendor workflows
• Procurement momentum disappears
• Business teams resist disruption.

Even if risk concerns appear later, change becomes difficult.

Vendors know this.

That’s why procurement and renewal are the best moments to negotiate improvements.

How Security Teams Use Risk Data in Negotiations

Modern procurement decisions increasingly include security teams early in the process.

Risk intelligence helps teams:

1) Justify Security Requirements

Objective risk data supports requests for better controls or commitments.

2) Negotiate Contract Terms

Teams can push for:

• Shorter breach notification windows
• Audit rights
• Security certification commitments
• Data handling guarantees

3) Require Insurance Coverage

Cyber insurance requirements reduce financial exposure.

4) Push Product Security Improvements

Security gaps identified during evaluation often become roadmap commitments.

5) Reduce Future Operational Risk

Better terms today reduce incident response headaches later.

Renewal Is a Second Chance

Contract renewal gives teams another opportunity to reduce risk.

At renewal, organizations can:

• Reassess vendor security posture
• Adjust contractual protections
• Address risks discovered during operations
• Update insurance and compliance requirements

Renewal negotiations are often easier because vendors want to keep existing customers.

Security as a Business Enabler

Security teams sometimes fear being seen as blockers in procurement.

But strong vendor risk programs actually help businesses make safer decisions faster.

When risk insights are clear:

• Procurement moves faster
• Stakeholders understand tradeoffs
• Vendor selection improves
• Future incidents become less likely

Security becomes a partner instead of an obstacle.

The Future: Risk Intelligence in Every Procurement Decision

Leading organizations now integrate risk intelligence directly into procurement workflows.

Vendor evaluation increasingly includes:

• Continuous risk monitoring
• Security posture scoring
• Compliance verification
• Exposure tracking

Security is becoming a standard procurement requirement.

—

The biggest vendor risk decisions don’t happen after onboarding.

They happen before the contract is signed or when renewal approaches.

Because once the deal is done, leverage fades.

And the organizations that use risk intelligence early are the ones that secure stronger protections, reduce exposure, and avoid painful vendor surprises later.